|
|
(41 intermediate revisions by 10 users not shown) |
Line 1: |
Line 1: |
| There's been some rolling discussion of how research publishing should work (i.e., might be improved), especially as it relates to Synthetic Biology.
| | It was decided at the retreat to set up a new publishing group (John, Julius, Drew and Jason) to look into a new mechanism for publishing pages on OWW. |
|
| |
|
| <font color="red">I'd like to propose a BYO working lunch on Thursday '''October 6 from noon to 1:30p''' to discuss current thoughts.</font> <br>
| | ==Announcements== |
| If this date/time don't work, please suggest another date time (before October 10).
| | *'''8.7.06: '''Please see [[OpenWetWare:Information management/a model for novel publishing | recent discussion and ideas since retreat]] |
| | *'''8.7.06: '''Please see [[OpenWetWare:publishing group/Reddit idea| details on the reddit idea]] |
| | *'''10.20.07: ''' [http://materialtransfer.org Materialtransfer.org] launched as a user generated information repository for finding, sharing, and reviewing scientific materials. Self-archive feature allows you to inform the community about your work/materials without losing your rights to publish in journals like Science and JACS. |
|
| |
|
| '''Possible Dates:'''
| | ==Past Meetings== |
| | *[[Publishing Group/Meeting 10-4-05|10/4/05]] <br> |
| | *[[Publishing Group/Meeting 10-6-05|10/6/05]]<br> |
| | *[[Publishing Group/old discussion items and comments]] |
|
| |
|
| This needs to be coordinated with [[Endy: Journal Club: Le et al 2005 | journal club]]. Journal Club will be on Friday, October 7th.
| | ==Refs== |
| | | [http://papers.nber.org/papers/W13272 Is peer review in decline?] (study of submissions to economics journals) |
| *October 3rd (Mon) from noon to 1:30pm
| |
| #[[Jason Kelly]]
| |
| #[[Barry Canton]]
| |
| #[[Reshma Shetty]]
| |
| #[[Samantha Sutton]]
| |
| #[[Caitlin Conboy|Caitlin]]
| |
| #[[Natalie Kuldell]]
| |
| #[[User:Skosuri|Sri Kosuri]]
| |
| | |
| *October 4th (Tues) from noon to 1:30pm
| |
| #[[Jason Kelly]]
| |
| #[[Barry Canton]]
| |
| #[[Reshma Shetty]]
| |
| #[[Austin Che]]
| |
| #[[Samantha Sutton]] but would prefer Monday instead.
| |
| #[[Caitlin Conboy|Caitlin]]
| |
| #[[User:Skosuri|Sri Kosuri]]
| |
| #[[Drew Endy|Drew]]
| |
| | |
| *October 5th (Weds) from '''1-2:30pm'''?
| |
| :<font color="red">(Ty's BATS talk 12-1)</font>
| |
| #[[Jason Kelly]]
| |
| #[[Barry Canton]]
| |
| #[[Reshma Shetty]]
| |
| #[[Austin Che]]
| |
| #[[Caitlin Conboy|Caitlin]]
| |
| #[[Natalie Kuldell]]
| |
| #[[User:Skosuri|Sri Kosuri]]
| |
| | |
| *October 6th (Thurs) from noon to 1:30pm
| |
| #[[Reshma Shetty]]
| |
| #[[Austin Che]]
| |
| #[[Drew_Endy | Drew]] (previously confirmed for Oct 6)
| |
| #[[Natalie Kuldell| Natalie]] (previously confirmed for Oct 6)
| |
| #[[Pam Silver]] (previously confirmed for Oct 6)
| |
| #[[Samantha Sutton|Samantha]] (previously confirmed for Oct 6)
| |
| #[[Caitlin Conboy|Caitlin]] (previously confirmed for Oct 6)
| |
| #[[Julie Norville]]
| |
| | |
| *(October 7th (Fri) is theory lunch Drew emailed about @ Harvard @ noon, in case people were planning on going to that.)
| |
| **[[Endy: Journal Club: Le et al 2005 | journal club]] to follow.
| |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| Please add your name to the list if you will attend.<br>
| |
| Please add your ideas/questions below that you would like to discuss.<br>
| |
| | |
| Attending:
| |
| #[[Drew_Endy | Drew]]
| |
| #[[Barry Canton|BC]] - can't make it before 1pm
| |
| #[[Reshma Shetty | Reshma]]
| |
| #[[Natalie Kuldell| Natalie]]
| |
| #[[Austin Che]]
| |
| #[[Jason Kelly|Jason]] - can't make it until >2:30.
| |
| #[[Pam Silver]]
| |
| #[[Samantha Sutton|Samantha]]
| |
| #[[Caitlin Conboy|Caitlin]]
| |
| #[[Julie Norville]]
| |
| #[[User:Skosuri|Sri Kosuri]]
| |
| | |
| Things to discuss:
| |
| #Do we need a Synthetic Biology specific journal?
| |
| #Does the peer review process, as practiced work?
| |
| #Is peer review needed for engineering research articles?
| |
| #What features would we like for our papers? Reader comments? Reader Wiki?
| |
| #How should the structure of a paper be changed to reflect things like, well, the Internets?
| |
| #What existing journals are the most appropriate/receptive venues for publication of SB work?
| |
| #How is publishing on SB topics different from any other field?
| |
| #What are the other (if any) alternate publishing models already out there?
| |
| #Non-synthetic biology improvement:Author IDs or URIs or something. Noticed this while trying to set up myNCBI searches for people with more common names, what a pain. I'm changing my name to xyuitk.
| |
| #Can we ensure that publishing and access to publications is equally open to all institutions regardless of rank?
| |
| #<your question/idea>
| |
| | |
| Relevant material:
| |
| *Hal Abelson and John Wilbanks gave interesting talks on [http://mitworld.mit.edu/video/270/ Open Networks and Open Society: The Relationship between Freedom, Law, and Technology].
| |