Biomod/2014/ASU/Results: Difference between revisions

From OpenWetWare
Jump to navigationJump to search
no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 145: Line 145:


h1, h2, #super-list, .box, .tagline, #index-list {
h1, h2, #super-list, .box, .tagline, #index-list {
   font-family: 'Lato', 'Helvetica Neue', Arial, sans-serif;
   font-family: Times New Roman;
}
}


Line 1,581: Line 1,581:
       </div>
       </div>
<div class="box b1x2" data-symbol="description" data-category="student">
<div class="box b1x2" data-symbol="description" data-category="student">
<p class = "serif" style = "color: #000000; font-size: 25px;"><span class = "mw-headline">Testing Tile</span></p>
<p class = "serif" style = "color: #000000; font-size: 25px;"><span class = "mw-headline">Characterization of DNA Antibody Formation and Structure</span></p>
                       <hr>
                       <hr>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">As a form of positive control, we created tiles of our basic design that could incorporate four random aptamers to specifically incorporate two aptamers known to bind alpha thrombin, called “aptamer A” and “aptamer B”, in specific configurations (shown below). The tiles were created using the tile assembly protocol under the Protocols tab of the Experiment section.</p><br>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">The correct formation of the DNA antibody was analyzed by native gel and also confirmed using AFM (shown below in Figure R1). The dimensions of the DNA antibody were measured and these corresponded to the expected sizes from the design. The DNA tiles stack end to end, due to their hydrophobicity, to form long DNA snake-like structures. White dots were consistently seen in the center of each DNA antibody, corresponding to the increased height from the cluster of aptamer strands.</p><br>
<img src = "http://openwetware.org/images/8/8c/Screen_Shot_2014-10-23_at_4.05.45_AM.png">
<img src = "http://openwetware.org/images/f/f9/Screen_Shot_2014-10-25_at_8.07.07_PM.png">
<img src = "http://openwetware.org/images/c/c3/Screen_Shot_2014-10-23_at_4.06.24_AM.png">
 
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">After the above tiles were created, they were incubated at room temperature with alpha thrombin protein at a ratio of 20nM tile: 1uM protein for one hour with gentle rotation. The samples were then run on an 8% Native PAGE gel with 10x bromophenol blue at 200V for 8 hours at 20 degrees Celcius with stirring. The gel was stained with Sybr Green and imaged by a Biorad Gel Imager. This process is an Electrophoretic Mobility Shift Assay, which is further detailed in the Protocols tab of the Experiment section.</p>
<p class = "serif" style = "color: #000000; font-size: 25px;"><span class = "mw-headline">Positive Control DNA Antibody Binding to Alpha-Thrombin</span></p>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">The resulting gel image below depicts gel shifts for the positive control tiles PCAB, PC2A, and PC1A, along with control tiles (tiles with filler strands in place of aptamers). The shifts of the bands to higher equivalent base pair values for all three tiles shown when protein was added verify that the protein bound to the tiles and added weight to them as compared to the bands for lanes in which the tiles were not incubated with protein. These shifts are representative of all of the positive control tiles, as they all bound protein.</p>
                      <hr>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">These particular tiles also show an interesting phenomenon: tile PCAB does not run exactly like PC2A nor PC1A. Both PC2A and PC1A show brighter bands corresponding to the bands in the control lanes; meaning that a much lower percentage of PC2A and PC1A are bound to alpha-thrombin compared to PCAB. The major band of PCAB runs as one band as compared to the two shifted bands of PC2A. We hypothesize that this is because PC2A has two of the same aptamers incorporated into itself, which can each bind a separate protein molecule. In contrast, the form of PCAB bound only to one protein coordinated between the aptamers on the tile is likely much more stable than a form in which each aptamer is bound to a separate protein due to entropic effects. This also explains the dearth of unbound tiles at the control band site: since this complex is more stable, it has a lower KD and fewer tiles exist in an unbound form.</p><br>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">Positive control DNA antibodies were constructed containing the aptamers with  known sequences which had previously been shown to specifically bind alpha-thrombin protein at different sites1. For simplicity, these aptamers were labeled “aptamer A” and “aptamer B”. The DNA antibodies were created using the tile assembly protocol under the Protocols tab of the Experiment section. The sequence for the control aptamers are listed in Table E1 under the Materials tab.</p>
<img src = "http://openwetware.org/images/a/a1/Screen_Shot_2014-10-23_at_4.11.42_AM.png"><br>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">The DNA antibodies were created to incorporate known the control aptamers in different positions on the tile. The number of aptamers and their orientation with respect to each other were also changed as illustrated in the schematic figure R1 below. Some of the DNA antibodies include a filler strand instead of an aptamer strand. This filler strand is made up of an oligo which only contains the sequence for the insertion into the tile such that when it binds, it “fills” the tile to be two dimensional.</p>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">This gel is representative of gels run with randomized oligonucleotide inserts. The six lanes on the left between the ladders are different dilutions of the 6th and 7th lanes: the 2nd and 3rd lanes are 10x diluted, while the 4th and 5th lanes are 3x diluted. On the right side of the gel are positive and negative controls for binding alpha-thrombin.</p>
<img src = "http://openwetware.org/images/0/08/Screen_Shot_2014-10-25_at_8.08.37_PM.png">
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">It is difficult to tell whether or not a small amount of the AT2R’ tiles in the protein-positive lanes have shifted. Optimisation is currently being done to try to recover any tiles that may be bound to protein but are too few in number to see with gel stain. This process involves cutting and eluting an area of the protein-positive lane above any visible signal, doing PCR for the randomized oligonucleotide insert strands, and comparing this to a control run with gel from the same area in the control lane. It is important to note that, though this procedure is susceptible to human error due to the difficulty of cutting the gel congruently in each lane, the overall outcome of the process can be tested in other ways. If the pool of randomized oligonucleotides is enriched, for example, assaying a new generation of tiles made with the enriched pool should show stronger shifts. </p>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">Positive control DNA antibodies were incubated at room temperature with alpha-thrombin and then were run on an 8% Native PAGE and imaged. This process is known as an Electrophoretic Mobility Shift Assay (EMSA).</p><br>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">The double nature of the bands in AT2R’ is characteristic of tiles of this nature: another previously-made tile, AT2R -- which incorporated two randomized oligonucleotides into the opposite sites as AT2R’ -- also showed such a signal in the control lanes. We suspect that this phenomenon is occurring due to some tiles failing to incorporate the aptamer strands. This should not be an issue, however, as the remaining tiles which have the inserts incorporated appear to be present in approximately equal amount, which should provide in itself a large enough selectable pool. Nonetheless, we are continuing to investigate the cause of the phenomenon and how it might possibly be prevented.</p><br>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">There was an obvious shift in the gel bands between the lanes containing only DNA antibody and those containing DNA antibody incubated with protein. This indicates that the protein is binding the DNA antibodies which alters the progression through the gel. These shifts are seen for all of the positive control DNA antibodies indicating they all bound protein. </p>
<img src = "http://openwetware.org/images/5/56/Screen_Shot_2014-10-23_at_4.13.19_AM.png">
<img src = "http://openwetware.org/images/d/da/Screen_Shot_2014-10-25_at_8.12.28_PM.png"><br>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">These tiles also show another interesting result. The tile PCAB does not run exactly like PC2A nor PC1A but instead shows a further shift on the gel. We hypothesize that this is because PC2A has two of the same aptamers incorporated into the DNA tile, which can each bind a separate protein molecule. In contrast, it appears that the PCAB tile bound only a single protein.</p>
<p class = "serif" style = "color: #000000; font-size: 25px;"><span class = "mw-headline">Alpha-Thrombin Selection to DNA Antibodies with Randomized Aptamers</span></p>
                      <hr>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">A new pool of DNA antibodies were made incorporating aptamers with random sequences after previously confirming the binding between alpha-thrombin and the positive control DNA antibodies. A native gel of the EMSA representing DNA antibodies with randomized oligonucleotide aptamers is shown below in Figure R4. From this gel, it is difficult to tell whether or not the random aptamer tiles (AT2R’) in the protein-positive lanes have shifted. The double bands in AT2R’ were seen earlier in other DNA antibodies that incorporated two randomized oligonucleotides into the opposite sites as AT2R’. We suspect that this phenomenon occurs due to incomplete incorporation of the aptamer strands into the DNA tile. However, there is still a large band of DNA antibodies with correctly incorporated aptamers to provide a large enough selectable pool and in the future, a longer program when annealing oligo strands will be used.  
</p><br>
<img src = "http://openwetware.org/images/c/cf/Screen_Shot_2014-10-25_at_8.13.18_PM.png">
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">To test whether the concentration of DNA tile bound to protein is too low to visualize with gel stain, a gel slice was cut from the region above 600 bp to just below the bottom of the well in lanes “AT2R’ w/o protein” and “AT2R’ w/ protein” separately, and the DNA eluted. These eluates were analyzed by PCR amplification using the randomized aptamer strands AT2R’, BT11A and BT16A (see Figure R5 below). </p>
<img src = "http://openwetware.org/images/9/9f/Screen_Shot_2014-10-25_at_8.14.33_PM.png">
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">Results of the PCR from the gel slice in Figure R5 proved inconclusive, so we progressed to testing the binding of the DNA antibody to alpha-thrombin using a NHS ester bead affinity column as described in the Experimental Protocol section with strand BT11 apt-A (a positive control). BT11 apt-A, a simple aptamer strand, is very similar to aptamer A, which is shown to bind alpha-thrombin in Figure R6 below.</p>
<img src = "http://openwetware.org/images/5/50/Screen_Shot_2014-10-25_at_8.15.35_PM.png">
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">This process was first tested using positive control aptamer BT11 and alpha-thrombin bound to NHS-ester bead.  The DNA was mixed in a column and washed with buffer to remove any unbound DNA.  Any DNA retained would be through binding to the alpha-thrombin protein. The DNA in resulting flowthroughs and column elutions were amplified using PCR and run on a 4% agarose gel and shown in Figure R7 below. </p>
<img src = "http://openwetware.org/images/b/be/Screen_Shot_2014-10-25_at_8.16.33_PM.png">
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">Surprisingly, it was found that DNA appeared in all wash fractions , no matter how many washes were done before the final elution. Therefore, we decided to test if DNA was nonspecifically binding to the beads. A negative DNA strand (BT11A) with no affinity for alpha-thrombin was used to test this theory. It was expected that no band should be present in the sample eluted from the column as the alpha-thrombin protein attached to the beads does not bind the DNA aptamer. Yet a band was observed in each experimental lane of this gel at 46 bp, the length of BT11A DNA strand (see Figure R8 below). Minor bands attributed to primer dimerization during PCR also occurred at ~30 bp. The major bands are of similar strength across all lanes, and the column material appears to have amplified as much as the other eluates. This would suggest that the DNA strands bind to the column beads and that this method is not suitable to test the binding of the DNA antibody to the alpha-thrombin protein. Another column was run with no protein and it confirmed this result as again, DNA was present in all elution fractions even though no protein was present in the column. Therefore, the DNA must have been binding directly to the beads.</p>
<img src = "http://openwetware.org/images/9/95/Screen_Shot_2014-10-25_at_8.20.41_PM.png">
<p class = "serif" style = "color: #000000; font-size: 25px;"><span class = "mw-headline">Amplification of aptamer strands for confirmation by sequencing</span></p>
                      <hr>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">During the process of DNA antibody selection and regeneration, the aptamers were the only element to be amplified. Therefore, the selected and amplified aptamers could be used to enrich another pool of aptamer strands for incorporation into more DNA tiles. Primers were designed for amplification of the randomized aptamers, and a test was run to see if these primers would amplify the aptamer strands. A 5% agarose electrophoresis gel of the resulting PCR products shows that we were able to amplify aptamer inserts for every insert site (Figure R9). Although PCR was run on known aptamer sequences, primer sequences were the same for the randomized aptamers.</p>
<img src = "http://openwetware.org/images/c/cf/Screen_Shot_2014-10-25_at_8.19.28_PM.png">
<p class = "serif" style = "color: #000000; font-size: 25px;"><span class = "mw-headline">Computational Simulations</span></p>
                      <hr>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">A pdb file of the control DNA tile was generated using CaDNAno and Cando used for visualization. From there, Avogadro was used to generate aptamer sequence, and the aptamers were manually inserted into the tile at the insertion points using PyMol. The structure was formatted.</p>
<p class = "serif" style = "color: #000000; font-size: 25px;"><span class = "mw-headline">References</span></p>
                      <hr>
<p style = "color: #000000; font-size: 16px;">1) Rinker, S., Ke, Y., Liu, Y. Chhabra, R., Yan, H. Self-assembled DNA nanostructures for distance-dependent multivalent ligand-protein binding. Nature Nanotechnology 3, 418-422 (2008)</p>
 
<hr>
<hr>
</div>
</div>

Navigation menu