BIOL398-05/S17:Class Journal Week 10: Difference between revisions

BIOL398-05/S17:Class Journal Week 10 (view source)

1,401 bytes added , 29 March 2017

482

edits

@@ Line 22: / Line 22: @@
 ==Lauren M. Kelly Reflection Questions==
+[[user:Lauren M. Kelly|Lauren M. Kelly]]
+#'''Overall, do you think this paper was clearly written? Why or why not?'''
+#*This paper was clearly written in some areas and confusing in others.  The methods and analytical methods were very clearly stated, therefore it was easy to follow what they were doing in the experiment.  It became less clear when they began bringing in results from other papers into their discussion.  I was able to figure out what they were saying, but the variety of information they were presenting all at once was daunting at first.
+#'''Based on what is written in the methods section, do you think you could reproduce their experiments/models and data analysis?'''
+#*I am unsure if I could reproduce this experiment.  While I know that they grew the yeast in four different environments, it is unclear how many replicates of each environment there were, or if there even were any.  I believe that I would be able to reproduce their experiment with further, more detailed investigation into what they did.
+#'''What else would you like to know about their methods, results, and future directions?'''
+#*I would like to know if they had any replicates of the glucose-limited/12°C, glucose-limited/30°C, ammonium-limited/12°C, and ammonium-limited/30°C chemostats. I would also like to know which genes in Figure 4 encode transporters, because the paper does not specify.