Melaminometer Project as proof of DIY Bio: Difference between revisions
From OpenWetWare
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
From: JonathanCline <jncline@gmail.com> | From: JonathanCline <jncline@gmail.com> | ||
To: DIYbio | To: DIYbio | ||
I would like to propose a real example regarding diy bio. | I would like to propose a real example regarding diy bio. | ||
Currently in asia, as reported on HK news, there are 10,000 babies in | Currently in asia, as reported on HK news, there are | ||
the hospital after being | 10,000 babies in the hospital after being poisoned with | ||
poisoned with melamine from purposely-tainted milk products. Note | melamine from purposely-tainted milk products. Note that | ||
melamine has now been found in M&M's, in oreo cookies, in | |||
been found in M&M's, in oreo cookies, in cereal.. I dunno about you | cereal.. I dunno about you guys, I like M&Ms. | ||
guys, I like M&Ms. | |||
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melamine#2008_Chinese_milk_scandal | http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melamine#2008_Chinese_milk_scandal | ||
Line 25: | Line 26: | ||
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Chinese_milk_scandal | http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Chinese_milk_scandal | ||
It occurred to me this week as I was attempting to buy some cereal | It occurred to me this week as I was attempting to buy | ||
over here in asia.. and | some cereal over here in asia.. and looking at the | ||
looking at the palettes of quaker oats "on discount", I'm not too | palettes of quaker oats "on discount", I'm not too | ||
encouraged that all the | encouraged that all the contaminated food is being, or | ||
contaminated food is being, or will be, actually disposed of. | will be, actually disposed of. | ||
I would like a melamine detector so I could test the food in my fridge | I would like a melamine detector so I could test the food | ||
and the food from the | in my fridge and the food from the store. Some of the | ||
store. Some of the contaminated food will get "curiously" re-directed | contaminated food will get "curiously" re-directed to | ||
resellers as discount stock and may be re-sold for years | |||
stock and may be re-sold for years through local channels - the locals | through local channels - the locals need this detector | ||
need this detector too. | too. | ||
So sure would be nice to have a cheap melamine detector. | So sure would be nice to have a cheap melamine detector. | ||
talking about something fancy, | I'm not talking about something fancy, like taking a | ||
like taking a sample of food to send to a lab which reports the result | sample of food to send to a lab which reports the result | ||
in 1 week or 1 day. I'm | in 1 week or 1 day. I'm talking about something I can | ||
talking about something I can stir up in the kitchen for years to come | stir up in the kitchen for years to come that turns red | ||
that turns red within | within an hour for "don't eat this." | ||
an hour for "don't eat this." | |||
This should be a simple DIYBIO project, right? | This should be a simple DIYBIO project, right? | ||
I am encouraged by open source biology because open source has been | I am encouraged by open source biology because open source | ||
shown to have the | has been shown to have the quickest response time for | ||
quickest response time for problems found in the field. Simple | problems found in the field. Simple example: When | ||
example: When someone found | someone found a major flaw in Intel Pentium chips, the | ||
a major flaw in Intel Pentium chips, the Illegal Instruction errata, | Illegal Instruction errata, and Intel admitted it was a | ||
and Intel admitted it was a | valid problem, it took the Linux community something less | ||
valid problem, it took the Linux community something less than a week | than a week (if memory serves -- something like 3 days?) | ||
(if memory serves -- | to come up with a runtime patch which scanned all | ||
something like 3 days?) to come up with a runtime patch which scanned | applications at runtime for the security risk. This was a | ||
very high tech solution to a very threatening computer | |||
runtime for the security risk. This was a very high tech solution to | security problem which "endangered" everyone who had an | ||
a very threatening computer | Intel computer. Whereas, Microsoft took months to release | ||
security problem which "endangered" everyone who had an Intel | a patch, and SUN microsystems I believe took even longer | ||
computer. Whereas, Microsoft | to patch their version of unix. Open source took days, | ||
took months to release a patch, and SUN microsystems I believe took | and commercial entities took months (not even willing to | ||
even longer to patch | admit there was a problem). | ||
their version of unix. Open source took days, and commercial entities | |||
took months (not even | |||
willing to admit there was a problem). | |||
Keeping all this in mind, how would I build melamine detecting | Keeping all this in mind, how would I build melamine | ||
"yogurt" in my garage right | detecting "yogurt" in my garage right now? I mean a | ||
now? | solution which is cheap (less than $0.50 per use), stand- | ||
I mean a solution which is cheap (less than $0.50 per use), stand- | alone, and usable by an 8 year old, so that the non-bio | ||
alone, and usable | savvy masses can test their own oreo cookies before | ||
by an 8 year old, so that the non-bio savvy masses can test their own | dunking them into soy milk, Shouldn't open source bio | ||
oreo cookies before | heads be able to get a working device validated in less | ||
dunking them into soy milk, Shouldn't open source bio heads be able | than 3 months? (BTW, if precursors etc to melamine needs | ||
to get a working device | detecting, then the device should do that as well.) | ||
validated in less than 3 months? (BTW, if precursors etc to melamine | |||
the device should do that as well.) | |||
A simple problem. At least from the applications angle. | A simple problem. At least from the applications angle. | ||
</pre> | </pre> | ||
</font> | </font> |
Revision as of 23:44, 15 October 2008
Project Proposal
Use of synthetic biology has been proposed by OpenWetWare and related individuals/labs/groups as a means for non-scientists to use biotechnology. I propose creation of a simple and much needed chemical detector as one possible method of testing the idea of "DIY Bio". This theoretical "Melaminometer" detector registers presence of both melamine and/or cyanuric acid; original proposal here:
Original Proposal
-------- Original Message -------- Subject: actually 'doing bio' Date: Thu, 9 Oct 2008 06:26:17 -0700 (PDT) From: JonathanCline <jncline@gmail.com> To: DIYbio I would like to propose a real example regarding diy bio. Currently in asia, as reported on HK news, there are 10,000 babies in the hospital after being poisoned with melamine from purposely-tainted milk products. Note that melamine has now been found in M&M's, in oreo cookies, in cereal.. I dunno about you guys, I like M&Ms. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melamine#2008_Chinese_milk_scandal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Chinese_milk_scandal It occurred to me this week as I was attempting to buy some cereal over here in asia.. and looking at the palettes of quaker oats "on discount", I'm not too encouraged that all the contaminated food is being, or will be, actually disposed of. I would like a melamine detector so I could test the food in my fridge and the food from the store. Some of the contaminated food will get "curiously" re-directed to resellers as discount stock and may be re-sold for years through local channels - the locals need this detector too. So sure would be nice to have a cheap melamine detector. I'm not talking about something fancy, like taking a sample of food to send to a lab which reports the result in 1 week or 1 day. I'm talking about something I can stir up in the kitchen for years to come that turns red within an hour for "don't eat this." This should be a simple DIYBIO project, right? I am encouraged by open source biology because open source has been shown to have the quickest response time for problems found in the field. Simple example: When someone found a major flaw in Intel Pentium chips, the Illegal Instruction errata, and Intel admitted it was a valid problem, it took the Linux community something less than a week (if memory serves -- something like 3 days?) to come up with a runtime patch which scanned all applications at runtime for the security risk. This was a very high tech solution to a very threatening computer security problem which "endangered" everyone who had an Intel computer. Whereas, Microsoft took months to release a patch, and SUN microsystems I believe took even longer to patch their version of unix. Open source took days, and commercial entities took months (not even willing to admit there was a problem). Keeping all this in mind, how would I build melamine detecting "yogurt" in my garage right now? I mean a solution which is cheap (less than $0.50 per use), stand- alone, and usable by an 8 year old, so that the non-bio savvy masses can test their own oreo cookies before dunking them into soy milk, Shouldn't open source bio heads be able to get a working device validated in less than 3 months? (BTW, if precursors etc to melamine needs detecting, then the device should do that as well.) A simple problem. At least from the applications angle.