Open Questions

PoPS, polymerase per second, is a derivative SI unit based on the base units of Moles and Seconds. PoPS represents the number of polymerase molecules that pass any specific position on a nucleic acid per unit time.
- Q. Is derivative the right word? Compound feels like a better word.

We are proposing that a relative measurement of promoter activity may be useful for reducing variation (across conditions and settings) in the observed absolute activity of promoters. This leads to several questions.

How should we measure promoters under varying measurement conditions?
- There is likely an analogy here to measuring length using a meter stick with a different (or the same) coefficient of expansion (compared to what, the thing being measured?). An open question is whether J23101 when measured under any conditions should always = 1 SPU (even if the amount of PoPS produced is changing). As I understand this is not the way that it would be done when measuring length - if you measure a meter stick at a temperature where it expands 8X then it is 8 meters long, not 1 meter. However, there seems to still be value in treating J23101 as = 1 SPU across different measurement approaches in that it would allow you to rank order promoters measured in different environments by different researchers. So not sure how to reconcile these two different points.
How should the reference standard and unit be defined?
- For instance, we could define the unit of the SPU as the # of PoPS from a reference standard promoter (i.e. J23101) under some standard operating conditions.
- We could alternatively define the SPU as = 1 PoPS.
- I think that the first option is likely to be the right one, but I think it could be influenced by the answer to the first question above.

Endy:Measkit draft