CH391L/S12/WikiEditing: Difference between revisions

From OpenWetWare
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 16: Line 16:


Remember:
Remember:
* It's not possible to make any mistakes editing that will cause permanent damage. So, be bold! At the very worst, your changes will be reverted to the previous version of a document.
* Be bold. It's not possible to make any mistakes editing that will cause permanent damage. At the very worst, your changes will be reverted to the previous version of a document.
* Your edits are immediately visible to the entire world. Be professional.
* Be professional. Your edits are immediately visible to the entire world.  
* DO NOT plagiarize or include copyrighted material (such as figures from scientific papers) in your edits.
* DO NOT plagiarize and be careful about infringing copyright.
 
== Copyright Issues ==
 
Copyright of scientific publications are a complicated and contentious issue. Most scientific work is publicly funded, yet published in journals that are run by for-profit publishing companies which handle editing and distribution. When you publish in these journals, you generally must sign over copyright of your material to these publishers. For work supported by NIH grants, authors are required to submit their final accepted manuscript (before copy editing by the journal) to PubMed Central, where they are freely accessible (but still subject to copyright).
 
Because we are guests on the OpenWetWare wiki, you should be very careful to not post any work from a scientific publication that may infringe on these copyrights. Posting copyrighted material may cause the people who run OpenWetWare to get "takedown notices" that they must remove certain materials from this website.
 
Then again, under the "fair use" doctrine of copyright law, you are allowed to reproduce portions of copyrighted works for non-profit educational purposes. There is a substantial grey area about what that means, so I am providing you with some guidelines, but in the end you are responsible for the decision on what to post when working on a topic.
 
Guidelines for "fair use" under copyright law:
* Always provide a citation and link to the original article.
* For copyrighted works, you absolutely may not post a full article or large portions of a article without permission of the publisher. Do not post PDFs of articles to OpenWetWare.
* Because you are creating scholarly works for non-profit educational uses, you may generally post direct quotations as long as you attribute the original article and they do not constitute a majority of the copyrighted work.
* In some cases, you may reproduce figures from a scientific paper directly in your page to comment on them.
** It is debatable under fair use, whether you can directly post a figure from a copyrighted article. For example, from Science or a Nature journal. You should generally avoid posting images from these types of articles to be on the safe side. It is better if you can make your own figure with the key information or describe it in words and attribute the original source.
** [http://www.plos.org/about/open-access/license/ PLoS] and [http://www.biomedcentral.com/about/copyright BioMed Central] journals are covered by the [http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/ Creative Commons License]. This license does allow you to reproduce their figures and upload them to OWW if you would like.
** If an article and its figures are available from [http://www.biomedcentral.com/about/copyright BioMed Central] PubMed Central], consider linking to the article and its figures in PMC.
** Selected articles in other journals such as PNAS are sometimes published under an "open access" option. Do not confuse this with being published under a less-restrictive license. These works are still subject to the same copyright restrictions as all other articles in the journal, although you are able to freely access to them on the publisher's website immediately upon publication. Consider linking to the article and its figures on the publisher's website.
 
=== Example of best practices ===
 
Check out the sources of images in this [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riboswitch Wikipedia article on Riboswitches].
 
Notice:
* The three-dimensional structure drawing is not from a scientific paper, but is an original image created by a user from coordinates downloaded from the Protein Data Bank (PDB).
* Many of the images have been directly contributed by a user who has modified them from the originals published in his own scientific articles.
 
=== For more information ===
 
OpenWetWare Copyright
http://openwetware.org/wiki/Copyright
 
US Copyright Office
http://www.copyright.gov/fls/fl102.html
 
Stanford Fair Use page
http://fairuse.stanford.edu/Copyright_and_Fair_Use_Overview/chapter9/index.html
 
Fair Use Check-List
http://copyright.columbia.edu/copyright/fair-use/fair-use-checklist/
 
PubMed Central Copyright Notice
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/about/copyright/

Revision as of 17:33, 22 January 2012

Register on OpenWetWare

You must register to edit the OpenWetWare Wiki to participate in this course.

Introduction to Wiki editing

OpenWetWare uses the MediaWiki system that may be familiar to you from Wikipedia.

First steps:

Remember:

  • Be bold. It's not possible to make any mistakes editing that will cause permanent damage. At the very worst, your changes will be reverted to the previous version of a document.
  • Be professional. Your edits are immediately visible to the entire world.
  • DO NOT plagiarize and be careful about infringing copyright.

Copyright Issues

Copyright of scientific publications are a complicated and contentious issue. Most scientific work is publicly funded, yet published in journals that are run by for-profit publishing companies which handle editing and distribution. When you publish in these journals, you generally must sign over copyright of your material to these publishers. For work supported by NIH grants, authors are required to submit their final accepted manuscript (before copy editing by the journal) to PubMed Central, where they are freely accessible (but still subject to copyright).

Because we are guests on the OpenWetWare wiki, you should be very careful to not post any work from a scientific publication that may infringe on these copyrights. Posting copyrighted material may cause the people who run OpenWetWare to get "takedown notices" that they must remove certain materials from this website.

Then again, under the "fair use" doctrine of copyright law, you are allowed to reproduce portions of copyrighted works for non-profit educational purposes. There is a substantial grey area about what that means, so I am providing you with some guidelines, but in the end you are responsible for the decision on what to post when working on a topic.

Guidelines for "fair use" under copyright law:

  • Always provide a citation and link to the original article.
  • For copyrighted works, you absolutely may not post a full article or large portions of a article without permission of the publisher. Do not post PDFs of articles to OpenWetWare.
  • Because you are creating scholarly works for non-profit educational uses, you may generally post direct quotations as long as you attribute the original article and they do not constitute a majority of the copyrighted work.
  • In some cases, you may reproduce figures from a scientific paper directly in your page to comment on them.
    • It is debatable under fair use, whether you can directly post a figure from a copyrighted article. For example, from Science or a Nature journal. You should generally avoid posting images from these types of articles to be on the safe side. It is better if you can make your own figure with the key information or describe it in words and attribute the original source.
    • PLoS and BioMed Central journals are covered by the Creative Commons License. This license does allow you to reproduce their figures and upload them to OWW if you would like.
    • If an article and its figures are available from BioMed Central PubMed Central], consider linking to the article and its figures in PMC.
    • Selected articles in other journals such as PNAS are sometimes published under an "open access" option. Do not confuse this with being published under a less-restrictive license. These works are still subject to the same copyright restrictions as all other articles in the journal, although you are able to freely access to them on the publisher's website immediately upon publication. Consider linking to the article and its figures on the publisher's website.

Example of best practices

Check out the sources of images in this Wikipedia article on Riboswitches.

Notice:

  • The three-dimensional structure drawing is not from a scientific paper, but is an original image created by a user from coordinates downloaded from the Protein Data Bank (PDB).
  • Many of the images have been directly contributed by a user who has modified them from the originals published in his own scientific articles.

For more information

OpenWetWare Copyright http://openwetware.org/wiki/Copyright

US Copyright Office http://www.copyright.gov/fls/fl102.html

Stanford Fair Use page http://fairuse.stanford.edu/Copyright_and_Fair_Use_Overview/chapter9/index.html

Fair Use Check-List http://copyright.columbia.edu/copyright/fair-use/fair-use-checklist/

PubMed Central Copyright Notice http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/about/copyright/